What Really Matters in Marketing
Review by Barry Silverstein
he lobbies for marketers to make an investment in their customers’ experiences.
By Tim Manners
Por olio © 2008, 280 pages, $24.95 (ISBN 978-1-59184-220-0)
There always appears to be more than enough books on the topic of marketing. Some of them reinforce commonly accepted theories of branding and advertising. Others are soapboxes for authors whose views are intended to shock, amuse or create enough con- troversy to get noticed.
That means taking a new look at radio as a conver- sational rather than an advertising medium. It means inviting customers into a dialogue via blogs and inter- active feedback mechanisms. It means basing the prod- ucts you develop on the insights you gain through your customer base.
Cornerstones of Relevance
In addition to insight, Manners discusses several other important aspects of relevance: Innovation, investment, design, experience and value. For each of these cornerstones, Manners presents case studies and quotes from experts.
That’s why RELEVANCE: Making Stuff That Matters is a breath of fresh air.Tim Manners, a long- time observer of the marketing wars, starts with the premise that many of the “best practices” of the past 50 years are no longer relevant. He questions the use- fulness of demographics, the coolness of buzz and the effectiveness of advertising. Manners focuses his laser- beam observations on what makes brands relevant.
Structuring the book into three parts –– problems, solutions and “what success looks like” –– Manners proceeds to pepper the text with case study examples from 87 brands and insights from 50 marketing execu- tives. While the rapid-fire nature of the book can leave your head spinning at times, RELEVANCE is packed with relevant and timely reportage and advice.
The Pursuit of Happiness
What makes brands great, says Manners, is “the pursuit of happiness.” Basically, it means keeping cus- tomers happy.“If you get the right people motivated in the right way, and you have a brand that people believe in, then you don’t have an issue,” says the for- mer vice president of marketing forVirgin Atlantic Airways.“We try to deliver employee value, which will deliver passenger value, which will deliver share- holder value.”
Manners takes aim at traditional advertising because “it does not help anyone solve any problems or live a happier life.” He points out that such companies as Netflix and Starbucks use word of mouth, sampling, and superior customer service, rather than advertising, to generate customer loyalty and grow their business- es. Advertising, says Manners, is simply an opportunity for marketers to deliver “irrelevant messages.” Instead,
Design is an area that deserves more attention than it is given in most marketing books, and the author doesn’t overlook it. Manners offers a particularly inter- esting analysis of the color yellow, which, he theorizes, became instantly popular in marketing many brands because of Lance Armstrong’s “LiveStrong” anti-cancer crusade.The yellow LiveStrong bracelet became a campaign symbol worn by millions of people around the world.
In a final section entitled “Relevant Outcomes,” the author suggests that growth is a by-product of rele- vance, because relevant brands “like their customers and understand them well enough to predict what they want.” Manners uses salient quotes from execu- tives at such companies as Patagonia, GlaxoSmithKline and Dunkin’ Donuts to hammer home his argument. The choice of companies is intentionally diverse in order to make clear that relevance is universally applicable. Manners also cites several old-line compa- nies that follow growth strategies.
RELEVANCE is a compact book, divided into short bursts of information that will make it easy for a busy executive to read it in digestible chunks.The concluding bulleted list of “Certain Secrets of Relevant Brands” provides a distilled summary of the main points cov- ered in the book. RELEVANCE is likely to be a very relevant read for anyone responsible for marketing a product or service. The Buzz Notability: Readability: Takeaways: Innovation: Shelf Life: