X hits on this document

Word document

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT - page 15 / 29

62 views

0 shares

0 downloads

0 comments

15 / 29

because " 'the ordinance protects both the vehicle owner and the public from towing mistakes, which may lead to dangerous confrontations, to the owner and his or her family being stranded at a dangerous time and location, to false vehicle theft reports, which waste law enforcement's limited resources, to unnecessary hazardous tows and to similarly unsafe circumstances.  The ordinance also protects against theft of vehicles from private property."  (Tillison, supra, 406 F.3d at pp. 1130-1131.)

City of Columbus guides us in analyzing whether the Legislature intended section 22658 to serve or further a public safety purpose.  Unlike the Tillison court, we are without an express statement of legislative intent as to whether section 22658, subdivision (i) was enacted to promote a public safety or welfare purpose.  As Tillison noted, in 2003 the California Legislature amended section 22658 to evince its intent that subdivisions (k) and (l) were adopted to promote the safety and welfare of the general public.  (§ 22658, subd. (m), added by Stats. 2003, ch. 212, § 1, No. 6 West's Cal. Legis. Service, p. 1643.)4  The legislature did not include subdivision (i) of section 22658 in that amendment.  These provisions compel us to ask whether the Legislature, when it set

4 Section 22658, subdivision (m) provides:  "(1)  It is the intent of the Legislature in the adoption of subdivision (k) to assist vehicle owners or their agents by, among other things, allowing payment by credit cards for towing and storage services, thereby expediting the recovery of towed vehicles and concurrently promoting the safety and welfare of the public.  [¶]  (2)  It is the intent of the Legislature in the adoption of subdivision (l) to further the safety of the general public by ensuring that a private property owner or lessee has provided his or her authorization for the removal of a vehicle from his or her property, thereby promoting the safety of those person involved in ordering the removal of the vehicle as well as those persons removing, towing, and storing the vehicle."

15

Document info
Document views62
Page views62
Page last viewedFri Oct 28 20:04:11 UTC 2016
Pages29
Paragraphs130
Words7802

Comments