X hits on this document

Word document

Peer Review for Interim Lighthouse Research Paper - page 1 / 1

1 views

0 shares

0 downloads

0 comments

1 / 1

Peer Review for Interim Lighthouse Research Paper

Paper author:

Reviewer:

1. Read through entire paper (without a pen/pencil in hand).

2. Read through paper again to answer following questions about content.

Assign a grade for the overall clarity of the paper:  

Comments on the overall clarity:

Assign a grade for the organization of the paper:  

Comments on the organization:

Assign a grade for the comprehensiveness of the paper:  

Comments on the comprehensiveness:

Comment on the comprehensiveness of the following specific topics:

Historical relevance:

Construction:

Upgrades & modernizations:

Lighthouse keepers:

Current status:

Future of the lighthouse:

Is the paper interesting?  Provide comments about the introduction, body, and conclusion of the paper:

3. Read/Look through paper to find grammatical errors and technical problems.

Underline errors on the paper (do not correct them).

Indicate spelling errors (sp)

Indicate grammatical errors (circle punctuation errors, etc)

Indicate if sentence is awkward /vague. (awk)

Indicate where wording can be made more concise. (w)

Give subheading suggestions for organization if necessary.

4. Write overall comments on paper.

Give content grade:  Give technical grade:  

Give overall grade:  

Additional suggestions for revisions:

Document info
Document views1
Page views1
Page last viewedTue Oct 25 05:36:23 UTC 2016
Pages1
Paragraphs30
Words183

Comments